Jump to content
Free downloads from TNA ×
The Great War (1914-1918) Forum

Remembered Today:

Mitchell and Agnew disappeared Nov 1920 at Macroom


corisande

Recommended Posts

Two ADRIC Intelligence officers disappeared on 6 Nov 1920.

Cadets Bertram Agnew and Lionel Mitchell are reported missing at Macroom, Co. Cork. It is believed that they were kidnapped by the IRA on their way from Macroom to Cork and then interrogated and killed. Their bodies were never found.

I can get background on Mitchell

1897 Jan/Mar born Chard, Somerset

1901 census living at Market Place, Crewkerne

1911 census living at 4 High St Newport Pagnell

Enlists in Ox and Bucks Light Infantry, and later transfers to Royal Berks Regt.

1918 Mar 28 LG Citation for DCM

1918 Sep 25. R Berks Regt. Temp. 2nd Lt. Lionel Ralph Mitchell, from Gen. List (I.A.R. of O.), to be temp.2nd Lt.

1920 Mar 20. R Berks Regt. Temp. 2nd Lt. L. R. Mitchell to be temp. Lt.

1920 Aug 17. R. Berks. R. Temp. Lt. L. R. Mitchell relinquishes his commission on completion of service, and retains the rank of Lt.

1920 Aug 17. Joined ADRIC with service no 298 ar C Coy, Macroom. Section Leader

Agnew is more enigmatic. All I can get is

1896 Born Lancashire

1920 Jan 14. RNR. Sub-Lieuts. to be Lieuts. Bertram V. A. Agnew.

1920 Aug 17. Joined ADRIC with service no 370. C Coy Macroom.

There do not seem to have been questions raised in House of Commons at the time of Independence. They just seem to have sunk from history.

Does anybody know anything more about them

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks Mark

Odd that the bodies were never recovered one of the Kilmichael casualties, Gutherie was put into a hidden grave, but the body given up in 1926. And this was in the Macroom area as well

Cecil Gutherie was the driver of the second Crossley Carrier at the Kilmichael ambush. Although wounded he walked over five miles trying to return to barracks at Macroom but was captured. He was held captive for two days and then murdered and buried secretely in a a bog at Annahala. His body remained there until 1926 when it was disinterred and buried at Inchigeelagh Churchyard.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

According to Richard Abbott's book, Agnew was born on 14 January 1896 and Mitchell on 8 January 1897.

Aled

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks Aled

It looks as if need to buy Abbots book :)

It might give me more to go on with Agnew. RIC roll says born Lancashire, but I cannot find a Bertram Agnew born anywhere then

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi,

Could he be 'Beitie/Bertie' ?

Regards Mark

1911 Census

57 Longfield Road Litherland

HOLLIDAY, Herbert H Head Married M 30 1881 Dock Labourer Batley Yorks

HOLLIDAY, Emily Wife Married

5 years F 27 1884 Liverpool Lanc

HOLLIDAY, Elsie Daughter F 4 1907 Liverpool Lanc

HOLLIDAY, Harry Son M 2 1909 Liverpool Lanc

AGNEW, Annie Mother In Law Widow F 70 1841 Holywell Wales Resident

AGNEW, Beitie Adopted Son M 14 1897 Apprentice Painter Liverpool Lanc

AGNEW, Dolly Adopted Daughter F 6 1905 Liverpool Lanc

CHATTERTON, Charlie M 0 (2 MONTHS) 1911 Liverpool Lanc

1901 Census

59, Tagus Street, Toxteth Park

AGNEW, Annie Head Widow F 60 1841 Nurse (Monthly) Holywell Flintshire

AGNEW, Emily Daughter Single F 16 1885 Liverpool Lancashire

AGNEW, Bertie Son Single M 3 1898 Liverpool Lancashire

COWARD, James Boarder Married M 68 1833 Living On Own Means Feeble Minded Kendal Westmorland

COWARD, Sarah Boarder Married F 49 1852 London

ELLARD, Mary Visitor Married F 34 1867 Rhyl Flintshire

ELLARD, Richard Visitor Single M 2 1899 Rhyl Flintshire

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mark

Looks spot on to me - great lateral thinking. I see he was adopted, as well

Thanks very much. These things tend to be like logical puzzles

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I reckon his birth is

1898 Jan 14. Born Bertram Vivian Archer at Toxteth Park and was adopted by Annie Agnew

Given his service record gives Bertram V A Agnew

He must have added a couple of years to his age to enlist

And found him in TNA catalogue

Name: Bertram Vivian Archer Agnew. Date and Place of Birth: 14 January 1897, Liverpool. Record Card Numbers: 49 - 51.

So my take on him is on this link

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Quite sad what one can uncover

Bertram was christened as the son of Adam and Emily Archer of 59 Tagus St in March 1898.

In Apr 1901 at the census a 16 year old Emily Agnew, daughter of Annie Agnew (Annie is his adoptive mother), is living with Annie Agnew and Bertram at 59 Tagus St.

And in 1911 census Annie and Bertie are still living with Emily who by now has married a Herbert Holiday.

Emily Agnew would only have been 13 or perhaps at most 14 when she had the child. Emily herself had been adopted by the Agnews

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have put a thread in the Navy Sub forum to see if I can get any more on his naval career.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi,

Here are his Medals listed, looks like must have been serving in 1915.

Regards Mark

Name: Bertram V A Agnew

Medal or Award: Star, Victory Medal, British War Medal

Service Year: 1914-1920

Service Location: Europe

Campaign or Service: World War I

post-14045-0-90851500-1303545784.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks Mark

I have found now from the Naval Forum that he was a sub-Lt from Jan 1918, and served after that on the Flower Class sloop, Honeysuckle

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi,

The WW1 Flower Class were purpose built as Minesweepers. They had reinforced bows to improve survivability if struck by a mine. In 1917 they were re-fitted to carry depth charges and re-deployed as Convoy Escorts.

Regards Mark

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I got a lot about the naval side of his life on the naval sub forum thread I started. The person supplying the info there specialised in Flower Class sloops.

He leads me back for Agnew in the RNR to his enlistment

1914 Oct 19 Midshipman RNR [probationary].

What is odd about this is that in 1911 census Agnew is a 14 year old "apprentice painter" in a poor household in Liverpool, and 3 years later is a midshipman in RNR

That naval-sub forum also gave me the regulations for becoming a midshipman, and he would have had to have been at a training establishment for two years to qualify. It is difficult to see how he could have achieved this. Though his baptism cert does say that his natural father was a "mariner", but I cannot find him in 1901 or 1911 census. Mind you his name may be incorrect.

I am fairly sure now that Agnew's mother was only 13 when he was born, and she would have conceived at the age of 12 and a half. It is impossible at this distance to say if it was promiscuity, naivety, rape or any other reason.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi,

They both appear on this Memorial Tablet from Irish Times 26 April 1924.

Regards Mark

post-14045-0-30129000-1303648543.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi,

I noticed on the Citation for Lionel Mitchel's DCM it mentions 'St Pauls Churchyard. I was wondering what it is in reference too?

For his Ox and Bucks Light Infantry service number 22875 the nearest service numbers I can find are

22864 enlisted 17 March 1916

22865 enlisted 14 March 1916

22866 enlisted 22 March 1916

So I think he most likely enlisted around March 1916?

Regards Mark

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ok there are two things bugging me now

1. As Mark points out what does "St Pauls Churchyard" refer to in DCM citation. I have no idea and it was written well before he died. This is the cut and paste from LG

dcm-citation.jpg

2. Agnew is repeatedly quoted as DSC, but people have helpfully told me

He is not in Fevyer's roll for the DSC 1901-38.

There is no mention of him having a DSC in the December 1918 Navy List.

So I am doubtful that he had DSC

3, Mark I would be grateful if you could add the bottom of that post about compensation you made in post #2. which ends with saying the father got £600 and the mother ....???

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi,

Have checked some other service records and I think he must have enlisted in St Paul's Churchyard, London.

For post #2 the word after mother is just a blur on the site but I think it is £?00.

Regards Mark

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks. The compensation looks a bit odd, as if the father and mother are not living together.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi,

On the 28 Nov 1918 Army List

Special List

*2nd Lieutenant Mitchell LR 25Sept18 Empld with Ind Army (Res of Off) (on prob)

On the 27 Nov 1919 Army List

Royal Berkshire Regiment

Service Battalions (5th - 8th Bn)

*2nd Lieutenant Mitchell LR 25Sept18

Regards Mark

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks Mark

I still cannot see what is going on here.

He appears to have been commissioned into Indian Army Reserve of officers on 25th Sept, then straight on to Royal Berks Regt the same day.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Here he is on the Ofiicer's Long Number list.

Maybe the 'M I' is Military Intelligence?

Mark

post-14045-0-63541300-1303716328.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thank, I have added the reference to the things I need to look up in TNA in the summer when am there.

As you say it could be "military intelligence", but I don't know enough about it to be certain. My guess would be that he would have needed some background in intelligence to have been IO for that ADRIC coy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi,

Here is Lionel Ralph Mitchell's Application for appointment to the India Army Reserve of Officers

Mitchell, Lionel Ralph IARO IOR/L/MIL/9/608/41-43 [n.d.]

IOR

Regards Mark

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the reference Mark

Does anyone know what the attraction of applying for Indian Army Reserve of Officers was at that time. There seem to be hundreds of applications on that reference. Mitchel got his Indian Army commission and went straight on to a British Army commission the same day

It is as if they did it to short-circuit the commissioning process!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...