Jump to content
Free downloads from TNA ×
The Great War (1914-1918) Forum

Remembered Today:

Flying over the battlefields


iain mchenry

Recommended Posts

I currently hold a UK Private Pilots Licence. I am stationed in Mons, Belgium where I am a member of a local flying club. I have been in Belgium since Feb 02 and have spent a great deal of time flying over the Ypres Salient and can only describe it as fantastic. I am offering out my services to forum users if they would like to see the West Front from the air. However there are a few rules to be put down here:

1. I only hold a Private licence not a Commercial licence so I cannot make money from this Venture (Nor do I want to). I can ask passengers to help chip in with the cost of renting the aircraft. The cost to keep the aircraft in the air for one hour is about 95 euros (60 pounds). I would therefore ask each passenger to pay about 15 pounds per flying hour. This keeps me within the law and also in benefit to myself gives me flying hours in my log book at a cheaper rate.

2. I am a shift worker. I would only be able to fly on my time off and when the aircraft is available. This will NOT be a scheduled service. During the summer months the hot temperatures affect the aircrafts preformance so I may only be able to take limited numbers. The aircraft is a Piper Warrior, single engined, Four seat aircraft. I will take only two passengers max (no baggage, Camera equipment OK) During the summer hot period this may be reduced to one passenger.

3. The pilots decision is final. I will not fly in bad weather or when bad weather is forecast. ( I would rather be on the ground wishing i was up there that being up there wishing i was on the ground!!)

4. Make sure you have holiday insurance that covers you for light aircraft travel. (Most firms do).

5. This offer will not begin until mid to late August as I am currently deployed in Kosovo.

6. Average flying time from Mons to Ypres is about 25 mins. 1 hour is a reasonable time to spend over the Salient before returning. ( you'd be surprised how small the Salient is from the air). If you have any specific areas to see from the air I will be glad to help. Make sure you bring a reasonable map with locations marked on them. GPS locations can also be of great help.

7. I will also fly down to the Somme (only about 55 nautical miles from Mons as the bird flies) routing direct overhead Cambrai. The Somme has a number of restricted airspace locations around it so I will only fly when these are not active (No near misses with French AF Mirages please!!)

I would be glad to hear constructive critisism from people about theis offer, and any interested parties can contact me through the forum. I can tell you that following th Messines craters from the air, flying around Tyne Cot and seeing the Menin Gate and Ypres from the air is an unforgettable experience.

Hear from you soon. Iain

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This sounds absolutely fantastic. I have often thought it would be fascinating to fly over all these areas. I am sure there will be a queue.

Many of us Forum users are coming over to Ypres in the second weekend of April and I would think there may be some specific interest then. Please consider me as most definitely in the queue for this date and indeed for some other dates. I will contact you off forum.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ian, and others,

You need to read the proposition in full - and carefully, and note that Iain says:

5. This offer will not begin until mid to late August as I am currently deployed in Kosovo

That said it is a wonderful offer (I could be very tempted myself). I wonder if any resulting aerial photos of interest could be posted for us all to enjoy. No doubt crop free periods will also reveal earthworks and trench lines.

I can predict requests to fly and requests from others for pictures from the air of all sorts of sites.

If anyone doubts the value of aerial views you need only look at Trevor Pidgeon's brilliant account "The Tanks at Flers" to see precisely how helpful they can be.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dear all,

One thing I forgot to mention when I statred this topic was that I will post a reply a few days before I intend to fly. If anyone can't make it but would like a photo taking of an area or object from the air, let me know and I will do my best. I curretnly have on negative many ariel phots. Most of the Menin gate, Ypres Grand Place, Messines Craters, Plugstreet wood, Hill 63 (see the subsidence!!!) and Tyne Cot (words cannot describe). Unfortunatley being stuck in Kosovo at the moment I don't have my negative file with me. When I get back to Blighty I will let Forum users know through this subject. If anyone needs phots let me know.

Regards Iain

P.S. My flying IS better than my spelling !!!! :lol:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Fabiansson,

The aircraft I fly is bright red in colour, so look out for the Red-baron re-born!!!!

Iain :lol:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Jacky,

My old, old, old friend!!! I did't want to let the forum know your fear of flying!! Just let me know and an ejection seat will be available for you anytime!! :P

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great idea Iain I got your message.. however if you saw the size of me you might want to weigh me in :lol:

I flew to Jersey on a small aircraft and had to be weighed in...

August the first few weeks would be good....

Have had a look at Nils WW1 crop marks and now I am smitten.. as Chris said prepare to be deluged

John

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nils,

Would you be able to give me the Latitude and Longitude references for some of the WW1 crop marks in the Salient and Somme regions?

Regards Iain

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would have thought that the extent of the crop marks would be substantial on the Western Front - since the vast amounts of excavation should manifest itself quite clearly , although the very extent of it and re-digging may in itself obscure things. Interpretation will no doubt be difficult.

I also understand that dawn and dusk are best times to see crop marks since thet are side lit.

Interesting that British archaelogists still make use of the extensive and excellent range of Luftwaffe photographs of Britain.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Iain

A great offer and it may be just the incentive I need for a husband reluctant to visit the battlefield sites with me (yes, I know this is probably a role reversal!)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would like to say a huge Thank You to Nils for posting the link to the fascinating and intriguing pages on the archeology site.

I am very interested in the Great War in Alsace and I've followed the links on your page to those in German about La Linge, etc. Do you know of any sites with aerial archeological photography of the Alsace region, preferably in French?

Gwyn

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Aerial photographs of the Western Front remains are very fascinating and could be better for locating remains than trench maps, which often are biased. Crop marks are never biased.

If you are interested, see this map belov, which illustrates pre Roman and Roman sites on the Somme battlefield, surveyed by the legendary French aerial archeologist Roger Agache (Roger Agache, "La Somme pre-romaine et romaine: d'après les prospections aériennes à basse altitude", Amiens, 1978).

AGACHE_MAP.jpg

Iain, sorry I have not latitude and longitude references for the aerial pictures I have published. They are in this context only illustrations of other kind of archaeological methods possible for WW1 archaeology. You have to check it out yourself.

Concerning best times to see WW1 crop marks: Winter. Well, then it is not "crop marks", but the dug up chalk and lime is clearly visible at that season (if it is no snow that is). Autumn/Spring is better than Summer.

Gwyn, sorry, I do not know of any Web sites with published aerial archeological photography of the Alsace region (forests make aerial photography difficult, but there should be possible to find some covering some aeras). IGN have aerial photographs for sale (expensive), see for example: http://www.ign.fr/affiche_rubrique.asp?rbr...90&com_id=65233

/nils

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dear all,

I will add this post as a basic guide to those who wish to take up my offer of flying over the battlefields or asking myself or other friends to Photograph objects for you. Some objects can easily be photographed from the air . Some WW1 objects now have modern constructions or forests obscuring views around them. Whilst flying around built up areas I do NOT fly below 1500 feet. In open areas I can descend to 500 feet as long as I am clear of obstructions. The time of day and the suns position in the sky also play a big part in the taking of Ariel Phots. Here are some of the Phots I have taken and a short description as to how easy they are to see/Photo from the air.

Ypres City- No Problem Menin Gate-From Moat side depends on suns position

Hill 60/Larchwood - No Problems Caterpillar crater- V. Difficult due to the forest

St Eloi and Crater - No Problems Petit Bois craters- No Problems

Maedelstate & Pecham craters - No Problems Spanbroekmolen- No Problems

Kruisstraat Craters - No Problems Petit douve farm - No Problems

Trench 122 & Factory Fm - No Problems Plugstreet wood & Hill 63 - No Problems

Messines and Whitesheet - No Problems Xmas truce site - No Problems

Poperinge Town - No Problems Talbot House - V.Difficult due to street design

Tyne Cot Cem - No Problems Lissenhook Cem - No problems

Langemark Germ Cem - V.Difficult due to tree cover

Polygon Wood and Cems - No problems Kemmel Hill - No Problems

Sanctury Wood - No Problems Bellewaerde ridge/Railway Wood - No Problems

I could go on for a while, but these are the main places people ask for Ariel Phots of. If any one would like to find out how difficult an arial phot is of a location not mentioned please contact me on or off the Forum

Regards Iain

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Iain,

I would like to borrow a Hasselblad large format camera from a pal of mine to do some battlefield aerial photography - one step up from 35 mm. From past experience vibration can be a problem. Have you had this sort of problem. I wonder what the best compromise film speed would be ?

There are some nice aerial shots in Trevor Pidgeon's wonderful book "The Tanks at Fler"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ian,

I don't have a problem with vibration on board the aircraft (If we feel vibration PANIC!!!). However flying in the warmer weather normally comes with an increase in turbulence as hot air rises from the ground, especially at lower altitudes. Windy days usually do't help too much either. I use a Minolta Camera 35mm- 80mm lens and 80mm - 300mm lens. I normally use 200 and 400 asa film. I do not consider myself to be a professional photographer so it may be better to speak to someone with a lot of experience in the photography field. Sorry I can't be of much help.

Regards Iain

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I do have a very old postcard showing an air photo of Ypres (the complete town). Interested members can receieve a scan of it.

Gilbert Deraedt :huh:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I use a Minolta Camera 35mm- 80mm lens and 80mm - 300mm lens. I normally use 200 and 400 asa film.

I haven't got a clue what that is but would photo's on a normal camera come out and would you be available to fly on the 2nd last week in August ? one last question how long would you recomend staying up for (to get a good view of the battlefields ?)

Conor :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I do have a very old postcard showing an air photo of Ypres (the complete town). Interested members can receieve a scan of it.

Just saw your post is that the one used in John Giles book "Ypres then and now" ?

Conor

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Connor,

In reply to yor post, Yes a normal camera will work, its better if you have some kind of zoom lens. I will gladly let passengers use my camera (Its squaddie proof, thats why I have it!!) as I fly the aircraft. Just supply the Film. For a really good flight around the Salient taking in a lot of the sights I would allow about one hour. When you are buzzing around about 120 mph up there the Salient is suprisingly small.

Regards Iain

Link to comment
Share on other sites

To Conor,

I do not have the book "Ypres then and now" written by John Giles. I cannot compare the photo in this book with my postcard.

Gilbert Deraedt :huh:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...