Jump to content
The Great War (1914-1918) Forum

Destruction of Great War vestiges


mebu
 Share

Recommended Posts

Following the recent demolition of the large British bunker at Noreuil and others, some local military historians are petitioning the local authorities (Pas de Calais) to prevent any further destructions. It is accepted that some demolitions, such as the recent destruction of several Australian bunkers at Franvillers which stood in the way of the new bypass, cannot be stopped, but some certainly can be prevented.

Attached is a copy of the letters, with the address, being sent. We are requested to send a copy to the given address. I can give an approximate translation if anyone needs it.

Would anyone who would like to help limit the removal of such vestiges please help by producing and sending the letter.

Many Thanks, Peter

post-2649-1232624529.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Peter - the first part of the contents of this letter refer to a specific example (I presume at Noreuil?) which if repeated in a number of letters of protest against future development might not make much sense? To simply 'cut and paste' the above might not have the desired affect in France? Personally I wouldn't use the last line which states "I hope this letter arrives in in your hands, rather than being destroyed or thrown in the bin as is all too common with French administration." If a Frenchman wrote to a UK civil servant in those terms I know what the result would be!

I quite agree that these vestiges should be preserved but wouldn't this best go through something like the WFA or Peter Barton and the All Party Wargraves Group?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think Paul is being rather too generous. The wording of that letter is absolutely guaranteed to offend and alienate the Président and the Conseil Général, making it even more difficult for more temperate and diplomatic approaches to engage their sympathy.

Hopefully no-one will send a letter they do not understand, and no-one who can understand it will think it is a constructive contribution to the cause.

Mick

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"I hope this letter arrives in in your hands, rather than being destroyed or thrown in the bin as is all too common with French administration." If a Frenchman wrote to a UK civil servant in those terms I know what the result would be!

My eyes popped out on stalks at that one as well!

regards

Mel

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi,

I was rather annoyed about what happened with the Bunker at Noreuil. These places are of interest to more than just the local farmer/owner. That being said, I also acknowledge and respect the land-owners rights, but ........., please!!!!!. Ooops, Sil vous Plait.

Currently, I am trying to get the archeology and history section of the Ville d'Arras interested in WW1 artifacts and then see if I can make an approach to Pas de Calais (and Departement Nord). Don't like my chances but I want to have a go at it.

I recently found a 1.5 x 1.9 x 1.6m deep collapse in the field that was on the old German frontline at Bullecourt, straight out from the Digger Memorial but could not get anyone to pay any particular interest and as such the farmer filled it in. Damn, if only I was 20 years younger, I would have asked the farmer for permission to have a preliminary dig to see if there was a concrete entrance to be discovered.

But perhaps, I am only dreaming. Us greybeards tend to spend more time fussing about than getting things done.

Peter

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes, I agree with the apparent tone, I thought it a bit of a rant.....but it is from Frenchman to Frenchman, maybe not the way we would write to local government (although we may think unkind thoughts...).

Anyone who wants to re-phrase, amend or alter, please do so.

Paul, yes I agree with your suggestion re another avenue, copies are already with Stand To and Bulletin editors.

I think the important thing is that as many persons as possible send their disagreement about destructions.

Regards, Peter

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I recently found a 1.5 x 1.9 x 1.6m deep collapse in the field that was on the old German frontline at Bullecourt, straight out from the Digger Memorial but could not get anyone to pay any particular interest and as such the farmer filled it in. Damn, if only I was 20 years younger, I would have asked the farmer for permission to have a preliminary dig to see if there was a concrete entrance to be discovered.

I wouldn't bee too sure about farmers being as excited as you are, Peter.

Late 80's (when I was 20 years younger!) I found the remnants of a concrete entrance behind a farm near Menin Road, Ypres. Very excited, I started dreaming about exploring a forgotten tunnel full of artefacts, that had never been visited since 1918. To Boldly Go Where No Man Has Gone Before.

I couldn't imagine why the farmer never had checked the tunnel underneath the concrete. "And what am I going to find there?", he asked. "A flooded tunnel. And probably more tunnels. Pfff."

He basically didn't care. WW1 may be a hobby for us, for farmers it's mostly a nuisance.

Roel

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I quite agree that these vestiges should be preserved but wouldn't this best go through something like the WFA or Peter Barton and the All Party Wargraves Group?

As co-secretary of the group mentioned (with Peter B.), I'd be interested to hear more details, as I know the membership likes to be kept abreast of developments.

Peter D.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hello Peter, you probably got the gist of it in the first posting: some local historians are writing to the local council, Pas de Calais, to protest about destruction of vestiges, I think the recent demolition of the British bunker at Noreuil upset them. I think they were also upset that the demolition of the Aussie bunkers at Franvillers, not all of which were in the direct line of the new road, together with other removals which most of us have seen over the years.

I was asked by a friend over there and said I would circulate a copy letter to forum, WFA etc and hopefully increase the number sent.

I will be over there next weekend when I hope to get more info/update. Any development, I'll let your group know, although I suspect it may fizzle out as most contacts with local government seem to.

Regards ,Peter

Link to comment
Share on other sites

as the historical nformation officer for the wfa, am very interested in this and saddened. PM or message me any extra details you have. also put up on the wfa forum and message me on that, so i can show the committe which is meeting in about 2 weeks. we have a few issues like this to go through, and commitee wise, it appears its the way it is done.

matt

4731

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 weeks later...
I quite agree that these vestiges should be preserved but wouldn't this best go through something like the WFA or Peter Barton and the All Party Wargraves Group?

Cases like this continue to strengthen my belief that we need a European heritage designation, comparable to World Heritage Site status, but obviously not quite so exclusive. Sites proposed for protection would be those of European significance, reflecting our common heritage, such as perhaps, medieval monastic sites, or sites of Great War significance. This would elevate their status and, to an extent, avoid the problem of "orphan heritage" where British remains in France may not be accorded the protection that domestic remains would receive. Just a thought!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 7 months later...

Having read this for the first time tonight; 9 months later; I'd be very interested to know what has happened and whether any other artifacts have been destroyed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 years later...

I know i'm really late to this but where abouts in noreuil were the bunker/s ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In the heart of the village. It was one large double fronted bunker. There was an excellant wartime image of it with two MG 08/15s propped against the wall and a British soldier. You could do a now and then photo. Alas now gone.

TT

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Any idea where i can the image ? tried googling but got nothing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The image is in the battleground Europe book "The Hindenberg Line". I have a photo (non digital) at home taken a few years back. If no one beats me will scan and post later this week. TT

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you could that would be great.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...