Jump to content
Free downloads from TNA ×
The Great War (1914-1918) Forum

Remembered Today:

Royal's Blog

  • entry
    1
  • comments
    5
  • views
    559

Brothers who returned alive


Royal

456 views

I always think it strange in a way that all four oldest brothers (great great great uncles) went to France and returned. 3 out of the 4 were RAMC.

One was gassed but still lived until the early 1970's with his wife in a little chocolate box cottage.

One was Maj Gen Sir Smith Dorien's batman. After Smith Dorien lost favour with high command and was sent to Gibralter as Governor, my great great great uncle went with him and never saw action again.

The other two....i dont know about.

On the other side of the family, one of my great great great uncles was killed in his barrack room in Belfast by a friend after returning at the very end of 1918. They had been on the ranges and his friend had not cleared his rifle. As he was taking it apart, he fired off the round and shot him in the back. So sad to go through all of the hell of France and die in such a tragic way. I have a photo postcard of his funeral with full military honours in Nottingham plus newspaper clippings, his Victory medal and death plaque. Needless to say i check my rifle properly when firing live rounds!!

Has anyone else had brothers etc that went to war and both or all returned?

5 Comments


Recommended Comments

Royal

Accidental and other deaths after surviving the the trenches is extremely sad. I seem to remember one episode of 'Who do you think you are' followed Kirsty Walk's uncle. I believe he was in the Royal Scots, transferred to the Machine Gun Corps, won the DCM, and then died in the flu epidemic in 1918.

Link to comment

My grandfather and his three brothers all survived the war. all were commissioned, Three were infantrymen - KRRC then MGC, South Lancs - two of them - and my grandfather who was RE, joined under the Derby Scheme. All their P files were destroyed in the 2nd WW except Grandfathers and so our family records are extremely thin.

Royal

Accidental and other deaths after surviving the the trenches is extremely sad. I seem to remember one episode of 'Who do you think you are' followed Kirsty Walk's uncle. I believe he was in the Royal Scots, transferred to the Machine Gun Corps, won the DCM, and then died in the flu epidemic in 1918.

Link to comment

My grandfather and his three brothers all survived the war. all were commissioned, Three were infantrymen - KRRC then MGC, South Lancs - two of them - and my grandfather who was RE, joined under the Derby Scheme. All their P files were destroyed in the 2nd WW except Grandfathers and so our family records are extremely thin.

Royal

Accidental and other deaths after surviving the the trenches is extremely sad. I seem to remember one episode of 'Who do you think you are' followed Kirsty Walk's uncle. I believe he was in the Royal Scots, transferred to the Machine Gun Corps, won the DCM, and then died in the flu epidemic in 1918.

Link to comment

I have four great uncles (brothers) from Wheldrake, Yorkshire who were in different regiments. They all came back, one died in the 1940's but the rest all lived into relative old age. I thought it unusual for four brothers to go and come back, but maybe not then ...

I have researched them all with various degrees of success!

Link to comment

Two of my Great-Grandfathers were brothers and both returned, together with 2 Great Uncles who also survived the Great War. And they're ALL the members of my wider family that I know served.... It's probably explained by the fact that they all ventured off to (and from) different parts of the Great War -

1) Herbert Herring, in the Irish Guards;

2) His brother Harry Herring sent to Mespot;

3) Alfred Eke, who had emmigrated to Australia but joined the AEF, survived it from beginning to end;

4) Peter Wilson, RFA, posted to India.

Quite an ecclectic bunch!

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...